Up to $500 per violation
Allegation
Sought under NY Civil Rights Law §40-d, plus damages "in an amount to be determined" and attorneys' fees.
Parkwood Entertainment LLC, for Beyonce.com
U.S. District Court, S.D.N.Y., No. 1:19-cv-00053, 2019
1.67:1 contrast ratio quoted in the complaint
"the 'apply' button has insufficient color contrast. Required minimum is 4.5. Actual is 1.67."
Voluntarily dismissed in April 2019; no payment disclosed.
Read the complaint (CourtListener)
Court order + attorneys' fees
Allegation
No dollar amount stated. The complaint sought a court order plus attorneys' fees and costs under the ADA.
Finish Line, Inc.
U.S. District Court, S.D. Ind., No. 1:20-cv-02756, 2020
1.84:1 contrast ratio quoted in the complaint
"The white letters in the light green buttons do not meet the minimum threshold requirements ... This text has a contrast ratio of 1.84:1."
Ended in a consent judgment in February 2021; terms not public.
Read the complaint (CourtListener)
$500 sought in each
Allegations
Three New York complaints each sought $500 under NY Civil Rights Law §40-d, a penalty of up to $500 per violation, plus attorneys' fees.
AZEK, ABC Home and Oroboro
U.S. District Court, S.D.N.Y., 2024 to 2026
-
The AZEK Company Inc.
No. 1:25-cv-07126, 2025
Sought: compensatory damages of five hundred dollars ($500.00)
barriers "including ... insufficient color contrast"
Voluntarily dismissed; no payment disclosed.
Complaint
-
ABC HoldCo, LLC (ABC Home)
No. 1:26-cv-08145, 2026
Sought: compensatory damages of five hundred dollars ($500.00)
lists "low-contrast text" among "pervasive WCAG 2.1 Level AA violations"
Pending; no payment disclosed.
Complaint
-
Oroboro, Inc.
No. 1:24-cv-00675, 2024
Sought: compensatory damages of five hundred dollars per instance
"insufficient color contrast on the focus indicator"
Voluntarily dismissed in April 2025; no payment disclosed.
Complaint
Justice Department agreement
Denied liability
No payment. The agreements required the sites to be fixed.
Rite Aid, Meijer and Kroger
U.S. Department of Justice settlement agreements, ADA Title III, 2021 and 2022
"individuals with low vision encountered text and links that had low color contrast with the website's background."
That is from the Rite Aid agreement about its vaccine sign-up site. The Meijer and Kroger agreements describe the same problem. All three agreed to fix their sites, and each denied violating the ADA.
Rite Aid agreement · Meijer agreement · Kroger agreement (Civil Rights Litigation Clearinghouse)
Damages, penalties + attorneys' fees
Allegations
No dollar amount stated. The 2026 complaint quoted here sought statutory and compensatory damages under New York law, civil penalties and attorneys' fees.
21 federal filings, 2019 to 2026
CourtListener full-text search of federal court records, October 2026
"insufficient color contrast throughout the Website (WCAG 1.4.3)"
21 federal filings use the phrase "insufficient color contrast" about a website. The quote is from a July 2026 complaint, No. 1:26-cv-06139 (S.D.N.Y.), which was voluntarily dismissed the next day.
Run the same search · 2026 complaint